Stick by Stick, Big Tobacco Is Killing Africa’s Future: A Continental Call to Conscience

IN A NUTSHELL
Author's Note  ...The World Health Organization (WHO) has warned that Africa will see the highest increase in tobacco use globally by 2030, unless urgent measures are taken (WHO Global Tobacco Report, 2023). It’s not hard to see why. While other regions are taxing, regulating, and restricting, here in Africa, cigarettes are still cheap, advertisements still sneak through the cracks, and flavored tobacco products are still sold near school gates...

...A report by Vital Strategies and the Tobacco Atlas notes that Africa is home to the world’s youngest population, and tobacco companies are zeroing in—viewing youth not as lives to protect, but as profits to extract (Tobacco Atlas, 2023). This is not just marketing. It’s manipulation...

By Peter Unekwu-Ojo F.

Tobacco Control | Policy Strategist | Advocacy | Global Health| Public Health Champion Executive Director, Cedars Refuge Foundation | Abuja, Nigeria

unekwu2@gmail.com

+234(0)803-291-2097

 Stick by Stick, Big Tobacco Is Killing Africa’s Future

A Continental Call to Conscience

 

I grew up in Lagos, Nigeria’s heartbeat—where chaos meets rhythm and survival is a daily dance. Our home was close to Oyingbo Market, just a stone’s throw from the rattling bridges that spiral endlessly above the city: Carter Bridge, Eko Bridge, and the iconic Third Mainland Bridge, casting shadows over the rusted roofs of crowded tenements and the tangled mesh of roadside stalls.

In those streets, life never paused. Hawkers yelled prices through traffic. Danfo buses puffed smoke into the sky. And beneath the flyovers, boys no older than twelve would pass around sticks of cheap cigarettes, their fingers stained, their lungs already lost to smoke they barely understood. Tobacco was everywhere—sold in sachets next to groundnut, suya, and recharge cards. No one questioned it. It was cheap. It was normal. It was deadly.

Now, years later, I look back and realize that what we thought was harmless was, in fact, systematic harm—imported and expanded by Big Tobacco. A silent epidemic is creeping through African streets, stick by stick, breath by breath.

Africa: Big Tobacco’s Final Battlefield

Across the continent, tobacco giants have found a fresh frontier. With markets tightening in Europe and the Americas, Africa’s young population, weak regulations, and fast- growing economies offer the perfect storm for expansion. We are not just being targeted—we are being hunted.

The World Health Organization (WHO) has warned that Africa will see the highest increase in tobacco use globally by 2030, unless urgent measures are taken (WHO Global Tobacco Report, 2023). It’s not hard to see why. While other regions are taxing, regulating, and restricting, here in Africa, cigarettes are still cheap, advertisements still sneak through the cracks, and flavored tobacco products are still sold near school gates.

The Youth Are the Bullseye

In the alleys of Kampala, the backstreets of Accra, the taxi parks of Lusaka, and the corners of Port Harcourt, children are being recruited—not with jobs, but with addiction. Packaged in colorful wrappers and flavored like sweets, tobacco products are increasingly marketed to bypass parental warning and lure youthful curiosity.

A report by Vital Strategies and the Tobacco Atlas notes that Africa is home to the world’s youngest population, and tobacco companies are zeroing in—viewing youth not as lives to protect, but as profits to extract (Tobacco Atlas, 2023). This is not just marketing. It’s manipulation.

Counting the Cost: Not Just in Naira or Cedis

Every stick smoked leaves a mark—not just on the lungs, but on the economy, the household, and the nation.

In rural Malawi, where children labor in tobacco farms, entire generations are exposed to green tobacco sickness before they learn how to write their names.

In Nigeria, tobacco-related illnesses claim over 17,000 lives every year, a figure expected to climb without decisive action (BMJ Global Health, 2021).

Across sub-Saharan Africa, families spend their meager income treating cancers, stroke, and heart disease, while public health systems buckle under preventable burdens.

The economic toll Is staggering. Tobacco-related illnesses reduce productivity, increase healthcare costs, and deepen poverty across generations. According to Tobacconomics, African countries lose billions annually—money that could be used for schools, hospitals, and clean water (Tobacconomics.org).

Industry Interference: Africa’s Silent Saboteur

Even as governments try to respond, Big Tobacco fights back—lobbying lawmakers, delaying policies, and packaging harm as philanthropy.

In countries like Kenya, Zambia, and Ghana, tobacco companies fund school renovations, sponsor youth empowerment programs, and pose as “partners” in health—even as their core product kills. This is the wolf in kente, the vulture cloaked in community service.

The watchdog group STOP (Stopping Tobacco Organizations and Products) has documented widespread tobacco industry interference across the continent— undermining policies, infiltrating ministries, and exploiting political gaps (ExposeTobacco.org).

A Call to African Leaders: Rise Before We Suffocate

We cannot afford passive diplomacy or timid reforms. The time for coordinated, unapologetic action is now.

Here is what Africa must do—urgently, and without compromise:

  1. Raise Tobacco Taxes Significantly

Make tobacco expensive. The evidence is clear: high prices reduce consumption, especially among youth and the poor.

  1. Ban All Advertising, Sponsorship, and Promotion

Let no billboard, social media post, or kiosk lightbox glamorize tobacco again. Enforce plain packaging.

  1. Implement and Enforce Smoke-Free Laws

Public spaces must protect lungs, not poison them. Cities must become smoke-free zones—markets, parks, buses, and schools included.

  1. Keep Big Tobacco Out of Policy

Enforce Article 5.3 of the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC). No meetings. No backdoors. No deals.

  1. Invest in Youth Awareness and Cessation Support

Every school should be a tobacco-free zone—not just physically, but mentally. Train health workers and fund quit programs across urban and rural clinics.

  1. Strengthen Regional Collaboration

Let ECOWAS, SADC, EAC, and the African Union coordinate enforcement, taxation standards, and cross-border monitoring. Africa must stand as one.

Final Word: We Know the Smoke. We Choose the Light

Africa is not Big Tobacco’s dumping ground. We are not the continent of secondhand policies or third-rate protections. From the shadows of Oyingbo to the alleys of Addis Ababa, from the banks of the Congo to the edges of Soweto, a generation is watching.

Africa must not become Big Tobacco’s last empire. We have the tools. We have the evidence. What’s missing is unified, courageous leadership. Every stick smoked is a step backward for our health, economies, and youth. The conquest of Africa by Big Tobacco is neither accidental nor benign. It is a well-funded, deliberate assault on our health, development, and sovereignty.

We have lost too many to tobacco’s deceit. Let’s not lose another.

Let this be a call to arms for all African leaders: Stand up. Speak out. Act now. The time

to protect Africa’s future is not tomorrow—it is today.

This is our breath. This is our battle. And it is time to win it—stick by stick, country by country, life by life.

 

References

WHO Global Tobacco Epidemic Report, 2023 https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240077164

Tobacco Atlas – Vital Strategies (2023) https://tobaccoatlas.org

BMJ Global Health (2021) – Tobacco control in Africa: urgent need for greater investment https://gh.bmj.com/content/6/2/e004175

STOP Reports – Industry Interference in Africa https://exposetobacco.org

Tobacconomics Tobacco Tax Scorecard https://tobacconomics.org

News Flash 624: Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

News Flash Links, as part of the research project PEAH (Policies for Equitable Access to Health), aim to focus on the latest challenges by trade and governments rules to equitable access to health in resource-limited settings

Salema (Sarpa salpa) 

News Flash 624

Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

 

World Blood Donor Day 2025

BRICS (+) and the future of global health: Building materials in a multipolar world

Mistrust, Trump and Multilateralism: Key Ingredients of the Pandemic Agreement ‘Recipe’

Transfer of technology and know-how for the production of pandemic-related health products in the WHO Pandemic Agreement: The proverbial half glass

MSF welcomes Novo Nordisk’s commitment to supply South Africa with analogue insulin pens, but the price must come down to $1 per pen

Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices at a Crossroads

COVID Critics Dominate New US Vaccine Advisory Committee

Yellow Fever ‘Spillover’ from Animals in Amazon Basin is Fueling Cases in the Americas

Serum Institute of India signs a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with DNDi to advance the development of a new treatment for dengue in low- and middle-income countries

Children with hepatitis B virus infections, Democratic Republic of the Congo

First vaccine against swine dysentery disease recommended for approval

Drones Take on Malaria by Hitting Breeding Sites

Testing indoor residual spraying coverage targets for malaria control, Bioko, Equatorial Guinea

WHO issues first global guideline to improve pregnancy care for women with sickle cell disease

‘Gardeningʼ in the Gut: Tackling Antibiotic Resistant Bacteria With Vaccines and Friendly Bacteria

Takeaways from Implementing a Parent-Adolescent Intervention Targeting Early Marriage in Bangladesh

Self-report and proxy reports in survey data on female genital mutilation, Senegal

WHO calls for global expansion of midwifery models of care

How to centre mental health in displacement

UN: $29 billion appeal unveiled amid “cruel math” of brutal funding cuts

Accelerating Refugee Inclusion Amidst Devastating Aid Cuts

UNPO and University of Toronto’s Munk School of Global Affairs and Public Policy Collaborate on Grassroots Movements in a Fragmented World

Weaponizing Food Worsens Starvation

IRRI launches new 5-Year Strategy to drive sustainability in rice-based agri-food systems

Bonn Bulletin: Climate talks delayed by agenda fight

Navigating the COP29 climate finance outcome: pathways for SIDS and LDCs

Taming the High Seas: UN Ocean Treaty Nears Entry Into Force

World Unites to Save the Ocean But Will Promises Hold Water?

Ocean crisis demands a new kind of science

Tanzania Champions Aquatic Foods at UN Ocean Conference in Nice

 

 

 

News Flash 623: Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

News Flash Links, as part of the research project PEAH (Policies for Equitable Access to Health), aim to focus on the latest challenges by trade and governments rules to equitable access to health in resource-limited settings

Brown meagre (Sciaena umbra)

News Flash 623

Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

 

Now is the time to rebuild the global economic system

AUDA-NEPAD Invitation for Comments to the Draft Continental Regulatory Reliance Framework

WHO Advocates for ‘Sin Taxes’ to Offset Aid Cuts, as Trump Submits Rescission Proposal to US Congress

A Million Lives at Risk?

Congress Can Stop The Trump Administration’s Assault On Children

USAID’s Role in Global Health Supply Chain Programs and Implications of Aid Cuts: A Rapid Review

Funding cuts force new thinking for world’s largest refugee camp

EMA’s annual report 2024

Priorities for a New FDA

WHO: Fourth meeting of the International Health Regulations (2005) Emergency Committee regarding the upsurge of mpox 2024 – Temporary recommendations

New WHO Recommendations to Protect Infants from RSV

Motsoaledi’s big HIV treatment jump: Is it true?

Building models, building capacity: A review of participatory machine learning for HIV prevention

Global burden of chikungunya virus infections and the potential benefit of vaccination campaigns

Thailand: “Ever-greening” patents – the case of TB drug Bedaquiline

Bedaquiline Activity against Leprosy

The Unseen Fallout of War: Rising Antimicrobial Resistance

Global health and hope: African countries unite to eliminate visceral leishmaniasis

Mental Health in Crisis Zones: A Personal Look at Hidden Wounds  by Rasha Almashhra

MSF report reveals stark lack of protection and assistance in South Darfur, Sudan

UNPO Applauds MOSOP’s Peaceful Stance and Urges Dialogue Over Ogoni’s Land Oil Dispute

MPP participation at the 2025 ASCO Annual Meeting

Global land grab highlights growing inequality

Malnutrition’s Long Shadow Puts Children at Risk Today and in the Future 

WHO: CBDR central to climate and health action plan; Germany and U.K. dissociate

Commission adopts Ocean Pact to protect marine life and strengthen blue economy

EU Commission: Water resilience strategy

Namibia’s green hydrogen scheme grows veg in the desert

Pacific Ocean life at risk from noisy deep-sea mining

Nia Tero: Indigenous Guardianship the ‘Only Time-Tested Approach’ To Healthy Ocean Ecosystems

 

 

 

 

 

Mental Health in Crisis Zones: A Personal Look at Hidden Wounds

IN A NUTSHELL
Editor's Note  "What we need is not just more funding, but a deeper understanding: mental health is not a luxury. It is an indispensable foundation. Without it, children cannot learn, adults cannot function, and communities cannot heal" 

First-hand reflections here where the Author draws from her field of experience in mental health and psychosocial support in conflict-affected settings

By Rasha Almashhra 

Specialist in Mental Health and Psychosocial Support

Damascus, Syria

 Mental Health in Crisis Zones

A Personal Look at Hidden Wounds

 

In conflict-affected settings, mental health is often overlooked in the most critical aspects of humanitarian response. We talk about food, water, and shelter, but the silent wounds left by war, displacement, and loss are rarely addressed with the same urgency.

With my long experience in mental health and psychosocial support, I have witnessed firsthand how unaddressed trauma can quietly undermine entire communities.
In Syria, as in so many conflict zones, people are trying to rebuild their lives in the ruins of their homes, not just in the ruins of trust, safety, and meaning. Children draw pictures of tanks instead of trees. Mothers silently grieve for the children they have lost, while trying to stay strong for those who are still alive. Teenagers withdraw into silence. Men carry the burden of broken livelihoods with a steadfastness that only cracks behind closed doors.

But through it all, I have seen resilience. I’ve seen women create safe spaces in devastated schools, sharing stories and laughter. I’ve facilitated emotional support groups where strangers become allies in healing. I’ve worked with frontline workers: teachers, nurses, and volunteers who serve others while carrying their own hidden burdens.

Sadly, stigma remains a major barrier. Many still equate seeking mental health support with vulnerability or instability. The lack of culturally appropriate services and trained professionals exacerbates this. Yet, simple interventions like creating safe spaces to talk, integrating psychosocial support into schools and health centers, or simply listening without judgment can make a huge difference.

What we need is not just more funding, but a deeper understanding: mental health is not a luxury. It is an indispensable foundation. Without it, children cannot learn, adults cannot function, and communities cannot heal.

Mental health should be viewed as part of a “One Health” approach that addresses physical well-being, environmental conditions, and social structures. While the world rightly focuses on equitable access to medicine and healthcare, let’s not forget that healing the mind is just as important as healing the body.

 

News Flash 622: Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

News Flash Links, as part of the research project PEAH (Policies for Equitable Access to Health), aim to focus on the latest challenges by trade and governments rules to equitable access to health in resource-limited settings

Cleaver wrasse (Xyrichtys novacula)

 News Flash 622

Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

 

Webinar registration: Strengthening Leadership on One Health Through Implementation Research in Francophone Africa: Renforcer le leadership en One Health grâce à la recherche sur la mise en œuvre en Afrique francophone Jun 10, 2025

Health Organizations Drop Ad Agencies Working with Fossil Fuel Industry

Abusing the Patent System: Gilead’s Evergreening Strategy to Prolong Its Lenacapavir Monopoly

US cancels more than $700 million funding for Moderna bird flu vaccine

WHO outlines recommendations to protect infants against RSV – respiratory syncytial virus

Cracking the Cost Code: Why Transparency in TB is a Matter of Life and Death

$15.3 Million Unitaid Investment to Strengthen Community-Led Action on Drug-Resistant TB in 16 Countries

People’s Health Dispatch Bulletin #101: What’s next for the WHO after the Pandemic Treaty?

UN: Call for input for the UNGA-80th thematic report on “Freedom of assembly and association rights, collective action and human solidarity facing existential threat: preserving the fundamental principles ” (Deadline 16/06/25)

UN: Call for inputs on women, girls and enforced disappearances (concept note for CED General Comment n°2) (Deadline 15/07/25)

UN: 18th session of the Expert Mechanism on the rights of Indigenous Peoples

UN: 59th session of the Human Rights Council (16 June to 11 July 2025)

HRR773: PERVERSE LEVELS OF WEALTH INEQUALITY, AS WELL AS CLIMATE AND ENVIRONMENTAL CHAOS ARE SIMPLY FLIP SIDES OF THE SAME CAPITALIST COIN. (GHW7, PHM)

Corruption in South Africa’s Past, Present and Future: Visualizing a Systemic Illness in the Healthcare System

Inequality Bands: Seventy-Five Years of Measuring Income Inequality in Latin America

Unemployment of Doctors in Kurdistan: A Ticking Time Bomb for Healthcare

Medicaid Policy And The Future Of Black Men’s Health

United Nations Habitat Assembly adopts Strategic Plan 2026–2029 to advance adequate housing for all

What Would It Take for All Americans to Have Access to Healthy Foods?

More pesticide cocktails in your food

Harmful chemicals often migrate into tinned food – here’s how to avoid eating them

Childhood stunting is also stunting our economy. Here are five ways to fix that

The Famine Early Warning System is Back Online. Its Warnings Are Dire

Say the “F” word: Famine and the Need for a Collective Voice in Sudan

In a Changing World, Protecting Nature is Protecting Our Future

Report highlights lack of EU action on marine protection ahead of global talks

Life Below Water Goes Deep: Our Planet’s Greatest Untold Story

Financing zero pollution action for better health in the next EU budget 

World Environment Day: Plastic-free, sustainable care starts with nursing

Plastic pollution: A health crisis in Africa

Addressing air pollution to reduce dementia risk

Only 21 Countries have Updated National Climate Action Plans – Few Actually Track Health Benefits

 

 

 

 

 

 

News Flash 621: Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

News Flash Links, as part of the research project PEAH (Policies for Equitable Access to Health), aim to focus on the latest challenges by trade and governments rules to equitable access to health in resource-limited settings

Mediterranean rainbow wrasse (Coris julis)

News Flash 621

Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

 

Webinar registration: Landscape Analysis of Gender Integration in the Ethiopian Public Health Supply Chain System May 29, 2025

Seventy-eighth World Health Assembly concludes: historic outcomes, consequential highlights

Assembly Acts Against Digital Marketing of Infant Formula

Seventy-eighth World Health Assembly: daily updates

WHA passes first climate action plan after tense vote

28-29 May 2025 LIVE: WHO Executive Board 157th session

Member states allow WHO to use reserves for salaries and severance

African Union and World Health Organization renew strategic partnership to drive impact and strengthen health systems in Africa

Trump’s HIV funding cuts will also hit diabetes, cervical cancer and depression hard. Here’s how

WHO guideline on balanced national controlled medicines policies to ensure medical access and safety Rapid communication

1P1B1R: A Strategic Approach to Health Financing Amid Constrained Budgets

Effectiveness of workplace interventions for health promotion

Polio Eradication Imperilled by $2.3 Billion Funding Gap

Malawi battles mpox as cases of the infectious disease surge in Africa

8th Asia Dengue Summit 15-18 June 2025 Manila, Philippines

The world now has its first ever pandemic treaty. Will it make a difference?

First all-oral treatment for a rare but deadly strain of sleeping sickness now available and being used to treat patients in endemic countries in Africa

Changes to the use of antibiotic azithromycin

The Children of the Sierra

Diethylene glycol: Unnoticed threat in the landscape of fixed-dose combination medications

European Week Against Cancer: providing patients with high-quality healthcare

From Users to Decision-Makers: Why Digital Health Citizenship Matters for Youth Mental Health

World No Tobacco Day 2025

Online Abuse Is Undermining the Right to Health

HRR772. IF WE ARE TO SUCCEED IN SPEEDING HUMAN DEVELOPMENT, MALNUTRITION IS BLOCKING THE CRITICAL PATH

Certified to Stay? Long-Run Experimental Evidence on Land Formalization and Widows’ Tenure Security in Benin

To Improve Women’s Health, We Need To Rebuild Trust

China shifts from developing world’s banker to debt collector, says Lowy Institute

With aid shrinking, governments need clear evidence to navigate tough choices for food security

Solidarity not exploitation: we stand with food workers from farm to table

Revealed: The true cost of climate crisis for world’s poorest countries

Global Push to Protect Oceans Gains Momentum Ahead of UN Conference in Nice

Global temperatures could break heat record in next five years

 

 

 

 

News Flash 620: Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

News Flash Links, as part of the research project PEAH (Policies for Equitable Access to Health), aim to focus on the latest challenges by trade and governments rules to equitable access to health in resource-limited settings

Flying gurnard (Dactylopterus volitans)

News Flash 620

Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

 

Watch the 78th World Health Assembly sessions

WHO secures 60% of base budget for the next two years

WHA Approves First-Ever Procedure for Investigating a WHO Director General

The Costs to Global Health

EU pledges €2.3 billion at European Humanitarian Forum 2025

BREAKING – US Health Secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr Extends Olive Branch to WHO – With Strings Attached

Meeting registration: Second intersessional check in meeting ahead of WHA78

Meeting registration: EU-MiCare: Introductory Webinars & E-Learning Platform Launch Jun 10, 2025

Landmark pandemic treaty adopted despite pushback by some countries

Next Steps: Tension About How to Settle the Pandemic Agreement’s Annex

The Pandemic Treaty’s Failure to Confront Profit-Driven Injustice in Global Health by Juan Garay

The Pandemic Agreement may weaken, rather than strengthen multilateralism

Is global health security worth 0.01% of our gross domestic product?

An Evidence-Based Approach to Covid-19 Vaccination

ETF recommends updating COVID-19 vaccines to target new LP.8.1 variant

The proportion of people of 50+ with HIV has doubled in 10 years. What does that mean for healthcare?

Explainer: How Germs Outsmart Antimicrobials and Why It’s Making Us Sicker

Africa must lead the fight against antimicrobial resistance through hospital-based antimicrobial stewardship initiatives

From Evidence to Action: Building an Effective Independent Panel on Antimicrobial Resistance

Cross-Border Collaboration Gains Political Traction as Africa Targets Visceral Leishmaniasis Elimination

Mental health of the health workforce: the digital transformation and its tools

Enhancing Perinatal Health Through Equity-Centered Policies

Nutrition research must go local

Young people, food delivery, and corporate influence: It’s time for the public health research community to back youth leadership

Evidence missing to address burn death disparities

People’s Health Dispatch Bulletin #100: Four years of People’s Health Dispatch

HRR771. THE FULFILLMENT OF HUMAN RIGHTS IS STILL WAITING FOR MORE CLAIM HOLDERS TO GAIN COMPETENCE AND DETERMINATION TO STAKE THEIR JUSTIFIED DEMANDS ON DUTY BEARERS. (Mhairi Cowden)

Explainer: What Rural Communities in Tanzania Need to Know about Carbon Trading and Land Rights

Children Are Being Poisoned Because of Bureaucratic Inertia

Famine stalks Gaza as Israel blocks aid at the border

MSF denounces deliberate humanitarian catastrophe caused by siege on Gaza

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Pandemic Treaty’s Failure to Confront Profit-Driven Injustice in Global Health

IN A NUTSHELL
Author's Note



Between Profits and Lives: A Historical Perspective

Between 1998 and 2003, more than 12 million people died from HIV/AIDS-related causes, despite the availability of life-saving antiretroviral therapy (ART) since 1996–1998. The majority of these deaths occurred in sub-Saharan Africa, where access to ART was blocked by pharmaceutical monopolies protected by international patent laws. This article analyzes the intersection of intellectual property, pharmaceutical profits, and preventable mortality, and extends the critique to cancer therapies, COVID-19 responses, and the shortcomings of the new Pandemic Treaty. It concludes that global health governance continues to structurally reinforce inequality—placing market-driven profits over the lives of the poor

By Juan Garay

Professor and Researcher in Ethics and Metrics of Health Equity (Spain, Mexico, Cuba, Brazil)

The Pandemic Treaty’s Failure to Confront Profit-Driven Injustice in Global Health

By the same Author on PEAH: see HERE

 

HIV/AIDS: Deaths Amidst a Patent Monopoly (1998–2003)

Despite the discovery of effective ART by the late 1990s, fewer than 2% of people living with HIV in Africa had access to treatment between 1998 and 2003. The annual cost per patient—over $10,000 USD—made access impossible for governments and individuals in low-income countries. Meanwhile, pharmaceutical corporations enforced monopolies on essential medications, including:

AZT (zidovudine) – GlaxoWellcome

3TC (lamivudine) – GlaxoSmithKline

Efavirenz – Merck

Nevirapine – Boehringer Ingelheim

Kaletra (lopinavir/ritonavir) – Abbott

Stavudine (d4T) – Bristol-Myers Squibb

Indian generics producers such as Cipla offered triple therapy for $1 a day by 2001, but patent enforcement limited their global reach. Estimated pharmaceutical revenue from ART during that period exceeded $36 billion USD. This results in a chilling estimate: $3,000 profit per life lost, or $100 per year of life lost—a grotesque ratio emblematic of systemic global injustice.

Cost-Utility Double Standards

According to the World Bank’s 1993 Investing in Health report, interventions under $100 per life year saved were considered “cost-effective” in low-income countries—thresholds often enforced through international lending. In contrast, health systems in high-income countries routinely fund treatments at $30,000+ per disability-adjusted life year (DALY). This cost-utility double standard implies a 300:1 disparity in the valuation of human life between rich and poor.

“A system that values the life of the poor at $100 per year while funding $30,000 per year in rich settings is not a health system—it is a global moral selection machine.”
Cancer: Continued Profit Over Access

Cancer therapies exhibit a similar pattern of exclusion:

New biologics and immunotherapies often cost over $100,000 per patient.

Patent evergreening and regulatory capture delay access to affordable biosimilars.

In many low- and middle-income countries, cancer remains a death sentence—not due to lack of technology, but due to lack of access.

COVID-19: Pandemic Profits Amid Uncertainty

COVID-19 further exposed systemic injustice:

Vaccines were developed with billions in public funding but sold under monopolistic terms.

Pfizer alone earned over $80 billion in COVID-related sales in 2021–2022.

COVAX underdelivered, and equitable access remained elusive.

Regulatory approvals raced ahead of long-term efficacy studies, yet profits soared while many in the Global South waited.

Health Equity and Global Injustice: The Structural Roots

As elaborated in the SHEM (Sustainable Health Equity Movement) webinar series and recent articles on health equity metrics, current global economic structures generate enormous and preventable health disparities. Recent estimates indicate that around 16 million avoidable deaths per year are linked to global economic injustice—primarily driven by the hoarding of financial and natural resources by high-income countries.

Research published in PEAH – Policies for Equitable Access to Health (2025) shows that every $1,000 of per capita GDP above a “hoarding threshold” of $50,000 USD in high-income countries corresponds to the loss of one week of life for individuals living below the “dignity threshold” of $10/day. Furthermore, GDP levels above $20,000 per capita are often associated with diminishing returns in life satisfaction and wellbeing, making this excess a form of “wasted GDP” in ethical terms. These findings underline the structural violence embedded in global economic and health systems and demand a fundamental reframing of global priorities.

Source: PEAH Article – “Health Equity Metrics and the Ethics of GDP Hoarding” (2025)
The Pandemic Treaty: Equity in Name, Inequity in Practice

The WHO Pandemic Accord was meant to address the failures exposed by COVID-19. However, its current draft protects pharmaceutical interests rather than dismantling the structures that caused “vaccine apartheid.”

  1. Preservation of Intellectual Property Rights

The treaty reaffirms TRIPS obligations, rather than promoting waivers during emergencies.

It relies on voluntary mechanisms like C-TAP and the Medicines Patent Pool, which Big Pharma routinely ignores.

There are no mandates for compulsory licensing or IP sharing, leaving access dependent on the goodwill of corporations.

  1. Lack of Binding Technology Transfer

Equity and solidarity are invoked rhetorically but not codified.

There are no legal obligations for high-income countries or pharma companies to share data, know-how, or biological materials.

The proposed Pathogen Access and Benefit-Sharing System (PABS) lacks operational clarity.

  1. Market-Based Supply Chains

Prices are left to market forces.

Without public manufacturing mandates or price ceilings, affordability is not guaranteed.

The same dynamics of delayed access and corporate profit maximization will repeat.

  1. Public Goods in Name Only

The treaty fails to declare vaccines, diagnostics, and treatments as global public goods.

Public-private partnerships dominate, often reinforcing Western-centric power structures and profit motives.

  1. Geopolitical Asymmetries

Global South countries are expected to share pathogen samples promptly.

In return, they get delayed, limited, or conditional access to life-saving products.

This perpetuates a neocolonial model where knowledge, production, and profit remain centralized in the Global North.

Conclusion: A Treaty that Protects the Status Quo

The WHO Pandemic Treaty, in its current form:

Upholds monopolies rather than breaking them,

Evades binding equity mechanisms,

Relies on corporate voluntarism,

Ignores health as a universal human right.

Unless radically revised, it risks being a symbolic exercise—preserving the structural inequities that defined past health crises and undermining the very goals of global solidarity, justice, and preparedness.

 

Main References
  1. Garay, J. (2025). Health Equity Metrics and the Ethics of GDP Hoarding. PEAH – Policies for Equitable Access to Health. https://www.peah.it/2025/01/14273/
  1. SHEM Webinar Series (2023–2025). Sustainable Health Equity Movement: Ethics, Metrics, and Action. https://www.sustainablehealthequity.org/webnair
  1. World Bank (1993). World Development Report: Investing in Health.
  1. MSF (2001). Fatal Imbalance: The Crisis in Research and Development for Drugs for Neglected Diseases.
  1. Oxfam (2021). The Inequality Virus.
  1. WHO (2023–2025). Pandemic Accord Draft Negotiation Texts.
  1. Knowledge Ecology International (2022). TRIPS Waiver and COVID-19: What Went Wrong?
  1. CIPLA (2001). Generic ART Pricing Offers.
  1. The Lancet (2020–2023). Various reports on COVID-19 vaccine access and equity.
  1. The Lancet (2024). Sustainable Health equity today. Juan Garay and SHEM sterring committee. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(24)01339-4/fulltext

News Flash 619: Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

News Flash Links, as part of the research project PEAH (Policies for Equitable Access to Health), aim to focus on the latest challenges by trade and governments rules to equitable access to health in resource-limited settings

Loggerhead sea turtle (Caretta caretta)

News Flash 619

Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

 

BREAKING – WHO Director General Shakes Up Agency with Brand New Leadership Team

Change Course Now! Only International Justice Can Create Social Security

G2H2 Activities in May: Discover What’s Coming Up in the Next 3 Weeks

UN reform: Where to cut, how to save, and the need for smart reform

Ethical integration of research in public health emergencies: preparation, response and recovery

Artificial intelligence in public health: promises, challenges, and an agenda for policy makers and public health institutions

WHO: Public health round-up

WHO: Health products regulation and prequalification  – Learning Catalogue

Scaling Up Solutions: The Need for a High-Impact Innovations List

WHO and Medicines Patent Pool announce sublicensing agreement for rapid diagnostic test technology

Critical Global Shortage of Nurses Undermines Universal Healthcare

Nursing in India: Between Care, Stigma, and the Struggle for Professional Respect

Maternal Mental Health in India Through the Three Delay Framework

Despite Industry Donations, Children with Diabetes Lack Secure, Long-term Access to Insulin

TB Advocates Call for Joint Action Against NCDs and TB at the UN Multi-stakeholder Hearing on NCDs in New York

The commitment to ending leprosy

The 2025 Neglected Disease R&D Pipeline review: Time to close the gaps

Modelling health outcomes of a decade of HIV, malaria and tuberculosis initiatives, Malawi

Cigarette taxation and socioeconomic inequalities in under-5 mortality across 94 low-income and middle-income countries: a longitudinal ecological study

HRR769. PUTTING THE LAST FIRST IS THE EASIER HALF. PUTTING THE FIRST LAST IS HARDER, FOR IT MEANS THAT THOSE WHO ARE POWERFUL HAVE TO (BE MADE TO) STEP DOWN. (Robert Chambers)

Reviving action on child health—now!

People in Gaza starving, sick and dying as aid blockade continues

UN Warns of Record Hunger Crisis in West and Central Africa

Brazilian microbiologist wins 2025 World Food Prize

Health sector advocacy for repurposing agricultural investments affecting fruits, vegetables and legumes

Urban Refugee Policies and Legislation in Kenya and Uganda: 2025 Stocktake

Bill Gates commits most of his fortune to Gates Foundation, closing 2045

Trump’s aid cuts blamed as food rations stopped for a million refugees in Uganda

Transitioning to a Circular Economy: The Future We Cannot Afford to Delay

To keep millions alive after aid cuts, pull climate and other funding in richer nations, group says

Beyond Adaptive Social Protection What Role for Social Protection in a Climate Context?

Progress needed on climate and health goals, Timor-Leste

 

 

 

 

News Flash 618: Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

News Flash Links, as part of the research project PEAH (Policies for Equitable Access to Health), aim to focus on the latest challenges by trade and governments rules to equitable access to health in resource-limited settings

Striped seabream (Lithognathus mormyrus)

News Flash 618

Weekly Snapshot of Public Health Challenges

 

Exclusive: Full Text of UN80 Task Force Pitch for Streamlined UN; UNAIDs Merger with WHO

The Trump Administration’s IMF Policy Agenda—Surprisingly Mainstream but Not Without Big Open Questions

Meeting registration: Preparing for WHA78: Envisioning the WHO we need, Reflecting on the WHO we have May 7, 2025

Webinar registration: Growing Up Safe: Public Health Approaches to Drug Use Prevention and Treatment in Childhood and Adolescence May 12, 2025

Invitation to Collaborate on Regional Project Proposals: Advancing Societal Understanding and Care for Our World  by George Lueddeke

Leveraging the power of data for public and animal health

Southeast Asia set to miss SDGs to end diseases by 2030

Anthrax outbreak compounds security crisis in eastern DR Congo

Africa Risks ‘Sustained Community Transmission’ of Mpox – WHO

Measles in America: Causes, Risks, and Responses

Antibiotic resistance dates back millions of years, with important lessons for modern medicine

Gloves do not replace hand hygiene – reminder from WHO

Restraining Health Spending While Protecting Access: Potential For Bipartisan Action

Is this the new era? Funding for sexual & reproductive health R&D 2018-2023

UN report says aid cuts led to global development slowdown

Desperate Afghans Resort to Holy Men and Shrines as Aid Cuts Affect Medicine Supplies

HRR769. PUTTING THE LAST FIRST IS THE EASIER HALF. PUTTING THE FIRST LAST IS HARDER, FOR IT MEANS THAT THOSE WHO ARE POWERFUL HAVE TO (BE MADE TO) STEP DOWN. (Robert Chambers)

Transforming Health Responses in Humanitarian Settings: A Policy Agenda for Gender-Responsive, Trauma-Informed, and Decolonized Care

Zimbabwe Health Crisis – Govt Rejects Call on Mnangagwa to Act

What Is Modern Slavery: A Comprehensive Research

Rwanda confirms talks with US about taking in migrants

Health inequities are shortening lives by decades

Why Millions of Nigerian Children are Unvaccinated

A New Data Hub for School-Related Violence Statistics

Lawyer-Turned-Activist Bhuwan Ribhu Honored for Leading a Campaign to End Child Marriage

Lives at Risk After Some States Withdraw From Landmine Treaty

U.N. World Food Program to slash jobs, drastically shrink food aid

Supermarket Watch supports local food struggles

Kenya’s climate commitment sets standard before COP30

COP30: The Global South’s moment

Climate Change Is Silently Eroding Workforce Health And Productivity