IN A NUTSHELL Author's noteThe annual United Nations Climate Change Conferences have become the central arena for international climate diplomacy. Yet, after more than three decades of negotiations, greenhouse gas emissions remain at extraordinarily high levels, ecological degradation continues, and the inequalities underlying the climate crisis remain largely unchallenged. COP31, taking place in Antalya, Türkiye, from 9 to 20 November 2026, provides an opportunity not only to assess the effectiveness of climate negotiations but also to question the cost, scale and contradictions of the COP process itself. This article examines the financial, environmental and political costs of these conferences, including international travel, large-scale organisation and the influence of powerful economic interests. It argues that the transition to renewable energy and circular economies, although essential, cannot by itself resolve a crisis rooted in excessive production, consumption, resource extraction, global trade and unequal distribution. The article advances a universal ethical framework of 1.6 tonnes of CO₂ per person per year, including approximately 0.6 tonnes allocated to essential collective services and infrastructures. This would leave an indicative individual responsibility target of approximately one tonne per person per year. Such a framework must be understood not as a restriction on human dignity, but as a means of making dignity universally possible within planetary boundaries. The article calls for a profound transformation towards simpler lives, local and regenerative economies, global collaboration, fairer distribution of resources and political leadership based on personal ecological responsibility

By Juan Garay
Co-Chair, Sustainable Health Equity Movement (SHEM)
Professor and Researcher in Health Equity, Ethics and Metrics
Founder, Valyter Ecovillage
By the same Author on PEAH: HERE
What Is the True Cost of Climate Conferences? COP31 and the Failure to Challenge the Global Dynamics of Production and Consumption
Beyond renewable energy and circular economies: towards a universal ethical threshold, social and ecological justice, and a dignified simplicity of life
- COP31: another climate summit, or an opportunity to question the system?
The thirty-first Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (COP31) is taking place in Antalya, Türkiye, from 9 to 20 November 2026. These annual meetings bring together governments, international organisations, scientists, businesses, financial institutions and civil society to negotiate responses to the climate crisis.
Their historical importance should not be underestimated. The COP process has established a global framework for climate negotiations, helped develop scientific and political consensus, and produced agreements that would have been difficult to achieve through any other international mechanism. The Paris Agreement remains a landmark in this respect [1].
Nevertheless, the fundamental question is increasingly unavoidable: what is the true cost of these conferences, and what proportion of their enormous efforts is translating into the structural changes required to protect humanity and the planet? Previous analysis of the COP process has also questioned whether these conferences are capable of reversing the increasingly destructive trajectory of human activity [2].
COP31 has attracted approximately 92,000 registered participants, according to reporting during its first week, making it the largest climate summit to date [3]. The scale of this mobilisation raises legitimate questions about the resources required to organise the event, the emissions generated by participants travelling from around the world, and the effectiveness of a process that has become increasingly complex and expensive.
These questions are not arguments against international cooperation. On the contrary, global collaboration is indispensable. Climate change cannot be addressed by isolated national policies, and the countries and populations most vulnerable to its consequences must have a meaningful voice in decisions that affect their survival.
But cooperation should not be confused with the perpetuation of an institutional process that has become insufficiently accountable for its own environmental and political footprint.
The challenge is not simply to organise better climate conferences. It is to ensure that the conferences themselves contribute to changing the economic and social dynamics that make climate destruction possible.
- The financial and ecological cost of COPs
The financial cost of a COP is distributed across many budgets and institutions. It includes the host country’s infrastructure and security expenditure, the UNFCCC’s organisational costs, national delegations, accommodation, transport, catering, temporary installations, communications and the participation of thousands of organisations and businesses.
There is no single, consistently reported global accounting framework that captures the full financial and ecological cost of each conference. This absence is itself a governance problem.
A serious assessment should include:
- Public expenditure by host governments and participating countries.
- The cost of temporary buildings, installations, security and event infrastructure.
- International and domestic air travel, accommodation and local transport.
- The emissions associated with food, energy, materials, construction and waste.
- The private-sector expenditure and financial interests represented at the event.
- The opportunity cost of resources that could otherwise support climate adaptation, public health, ecological restoration and vulnerable communities.
The emissions footprint is particularly important. Thousands of people travelling internationally, often over considerable distances, inevitably generate emissions. Private aviation adds another dimension to the contradiction.
During COP31, reporting based on Oxfam analysis identified 94 private jet flights to Antalya during the period immediately preceding the conference, substantially above the usual level. This does not establish the complete footprint of the summit, but it illustrates why the travel and consumption patterns surrounding climate diplomacy deserve scrutiny.
A conference that asks humanity to reduce emissions must be prepared to measure and disclose its own.
The proposal advanced here is that every COP publish an independently audited financial and environmental account, including the emissions generated by its organisation and participants. This should be accompanied by a transparent assessment of the climate and social benefits achieved through the conference, rather than relying only on declarations, pledges and the number of participants.
The objective should be to make future conferences smaller, more efficient, more accessible to vulnerable countries and less carbon-intensive, while preserving the global dialogue that makes them necessary.
- The missing universal ethical threshold
One of the most important omissions in climate diplomacy is the absence of a sufficiently clear and universally applicable ethical reference for the emissions attributable to human activities.
The scientific community has established carbon budgets and temperature goals, particularly through the work of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. These provide essential guidance on the physical limits within which humanity must operate [4]. The UNEP Emissions Gap Report also highlights the distance between current national commitments and the emission reductions needed to meet global climate goals [5].
However, the scientific carbon budget and the ethical distribution of responsibility are not identical questions.
The first asks how much humanity can emit while limiting dangerous warming. The second asks how the remaining ecological space should be shared fairly between individuals, societies and generations.
This article advances a universal ethical reference of 1.6 metric tonnes of CO₂ per person per year, irrespective of nationality, income, social status or geographical location.
This proposed allocation includes approximately 0.6 tonnes per person attributable to essential collective services and infrastructures, such as healthcare, education, essential public transport and other basic services. The remaining approximately one tonne per person per year would constitute an indicative individual responsibility target.
These figures are a proposed ethical framework, not an officially adopted scientific or UN threshold. Their methodology, assumptions, accounting boundaries and periodic revision should be transparent and open to scientific and democratic scrutiny. In particular, the distinction between territorial and consumption-based emissions, the treatment of land-use change and the allocation of collective infrastructure emissions must be made explicit. Global emissions accounting and carbon-budget assessments provide important scientific foundations for this discussion [6].
The purpose is not to impose identical material conditions on everyone. It is to establish a shared ecological responsibility while recognising radically different starting points.
A person living in poverty, without access to adequate food, housing, healthcare, education or energy, cannot be expected to make the same choices as someone enjoying a highly carbon-intensive lifestyle. Nor should essential services be sacrificed to achieve an accounting target.
The ethical principle is precisely the opposite: every person should be able to live with dignity, while the collective and individual means of achieving that dignity remain within a fair share of ecological limits.
This requires a distinction between essential needs and excessive consumption, between public goods and private luxury, and between resources that enable human flourishing and those that primarily sustain accumulation.
The proposed threshold should therefore become part of a wider conversation about the distribution of ecological space, not merely another numerical target in climate negotiations.
- Political leadership must begin with personal responsibility
Climate agreements are ultimately implemented through decisions made by governments, institutions, businesses and individuals. Yet political leaders frequently ask populations to change their behaviour without demonstrating that they are prepared to apply comparable principles to their own lives.
The international climate process should establish a clear expectation that political representatives, ministers, negotiators and senior public officials know, measure and disclose their relevant carbon footprints.
This should include international travel, accommodation, housing, transport, consumption and other significant sources of emissions. It should also include a credible plan for progressively reducing their footprints.
This is not a proposal to exclude anyone from climate negotiations because their current emissions exceed an ethical reference. Such exclusion would be neither fair nor constructive. People and institutions must be able to participate in the process of transformation, including those whose starting point is far from the proposed target.
But participation should be accompanied by transparency and accountability.
Political leadership without personal ecological responsibility is an empty commitment.
If political leaders attending COP31 cannot demonstrate that they know their own carbon footprints, are committed to the proposed one-tonne individual responsibility target and are progressively reducing their emissions, how can they legitimately ask the rest of humanity to transform its way of life?
The same principle should apply to the institutions organising the conferences and to the economic actors seeking to influence their outcomes.
The objective is not moral perfection. It is consistency between public commitments and private conduct.
- Renewable energy and circular economies are necessary, but insufficient
The transition towards renewable energy is indispensable. Solar, wind and other renewable technologies can reduce dependence on fossil fuels, improve energy security and provide opportunities for more decentralised and equitable energy systems.
Circular economies can also reduce waste, extend the useful life of materials, improve repair and reuse, and limit the extraction of virgin resources.
However, neither renewable energy nor circularity automatically makes the present model of economic development sustainable.
A society can increase renewable electricity production while continuing to expand energy consumption, international transport, industrial agriculture, mineral extraction, digital infrastructure and unnecessary manufacturing.
A circular economy can still be an economy of excessive consumption if the total volume of materials and energy circulating through it continues to grow beyond ecological limits.
Efficiency gains can also be offset by increased consumption. More efficient vehicles, buildings and industrial processes do not necessarily reduce total emissions if the number of vehicles, buildings, products and journeys continues to increase.
This is why the climate debate must move beyond the question of how energy is produced and address the more fundamental question of how much energy and material humanity consumes, for what purposes, and who benefits.
A genuine transition requires:
- Reducing unnecessary production and consumption.
- Extending the lifespan of products and prioritising repair and reuse.
- Replacing resource-intensive supply chains with more local and resilient systems wherever possible.
- Supporting regenerative agriculture and food sovereignty.
- Reducing unnecessary international transport and long-distance trade.
- Protecting ecosystems and restoring biodiversity.
- Ensuring universal access to essential services and dignified living conditions.
Renewable energy should support this transformation, not provide an excuse to perpetuate the same patterns of excessive consumption under a different technological label.
- Global trade, local resilience and the possibility of simpler lives
The global economy has developed a degree of interdependence that can be beneficial. International cooperation enables scientific exchange, access to medicines, the development of renewable technologies and the sharing of knowledge and resources.
But the expansion of global trade has also encouraged the movement of enormous quantities of goods over long distances, often when equivalent products could be produced closer to where they are consumed.
Food may travel across continents while local producers struggle to survive. Products may be manufactured through complex international supply chains, assembled, packaged, transported and marketed at substantial environmental and social cost. The financial price paid by consumers rarely reflects the full ecological damage or the conditions of workers involved in production.
The proposal advanced here is that the possibility of reducing the volume of unnecessary international trade by as much as 80% should be seriously examined as a long-term ethical and ecological objective.
This is a transformative proposal, not an established scientific optimum or an immediate across-the-board policy prescription. It would require detailed sectoral assessment, international cooperation and safeguards to protect food security, access to medicines, essential technologies, employment and the livelihoods of communities dependent on trade.
The principle is to distinguish between trade that genuinely contributes to human wellbeing and trade that exists primarily to sustain excessive consumption, financial accumulation and avoidable transport.
Local and regional economies should become more resilient, without turning into isolated or self-sufficient enclaves. Global collaboration remains essential, particularly in science, public health, climate adaptation, renewable-energy technologies and the protection of shared ecosystems.
The objective is not to close borders to knowledge or solidarity. It is to reduce unnecessary material movement while strengthening the exchange of what humanity genuinely needs.
Food sovereignty is an especially important example. Agroecological production, local distribution, seasonal diets, soil regeneration and community-based food systems can reduce dependence on long supply chains while improving biodiversity, livelihoods and access to healthy food.
Such a transformation would also reconnect human wellbeing with the natural cycles on which life depends.
- Social justice and ecological justice are inseparable
The climate crisis is not distributed equally. Those who have contributed least to global emissions often face the greatest consequences, while those who have benefited most from carbon-intensive development have greater financial and technological capacity to protect themselves.
The same inequalities are visible in access to healthcare, education, housing, water, food and other essential conditions for human dignity.
A climate strategy that reduces emissions while perpetuating extreme poverty and unequal access to resources cannot be considered sustainable. Equally, a strategy that promises universal prosperity through unlimited material growth is incompatible with planetary boundaries.
The challenge is to guarantee the conditions for a dignified life for everyone without reproducing the excessive consumption of the wealthiest societies.
Previous work published in PEAH has examined the relationship between emissions, human life-years lost and the ethical implications of unequal responsibility [7]. Further work has explored countries whose emissions exceed the proposed ethical threshold [8], as well as the distinction between basic dignity and excessive accumulation, including the implications of excess and hoarding thresholds for intergenerational equity [9].
The Sustainable Wellbeing Equity Index, developed in this wider field of research, seeks to contribute to the discussion by questioning conventional measures of development that rely heavily on national income and economic growth [10].
Gross Domestic Product can increase through activities that destroy ecosystems, generate pollution or create unnecessary consumption. It does not adequately distinguish between economic activity that improves human wellbeing and activity that undermines the conditions for life.
Nor does it sufficiently reflect the unequal distribution of resources or the consequences of excessive consumption for people living in economically disadvantaged countries.
The ethical question is therefore not simply how to create more wealth, but how to ensure that existing resources are distributed in ways that secure universal dignity while respecting ecological limits.
A fair climate transition must be redistributive as well as decarbonising.
- The cost of excess: from financial accumulation to ecological destruction
Excessive consumption is not simply a matter of individual lifestyle choices. It is embedded in economic structures that reward accumulation, encourage planned obsolescence, stimulate demand and treat continuous growth as an objective in itself.
Financial systems can further distance economic activity from the material and ecological consequences of investment decisions.
Large volumes of capital may be directed towards speculation, asset inflation and activities that generate financial returns without corresponding improvements in human wellbeing. At the same time, investment in essential public services, ecological restoration and basic infrastructure remains inadequate in many parts of the world.
Artificial intelligence may intensify these contradictions.
AI has enormous potential to support scientific research, improve healthcare, monitor ecosystems, optimise energy systems and expand access to knowledge. But its development is also associated with substantial energy and material demands, concentration of technological power, military applications and increasingly sophisticated financial speculation.
A previous analysis published in PEAH has examined the risks of AI when the global good is not the primary objective, particularly in relation to the concentration of power and financial speculation [11].
If AI is primarily developed to accelerate competition, maximise financial returns and concentrate control over resources, it risks reinforcing the inequalities that already undermine global sustainability.
The question is not whether technological progress should be rejected. It is whether technology should serve the global good or the accumulation of power and wealth by a small minority.
The ecological footprint of digital infrastructure, including data centres, computing equipment, water consumption and mineral extraction, should be measured and publicly disclosed. Its expansion should be assessed against its actual contribution to human wellbeing and environmental protection.
Technological innovation must be evaluated not only by its efficiency or profitability, but also by its distributional consequences and its compatibility with planetary boundaries.
- Simple living: an old idea with urgent contemporary relevance
The idea that human wellbeing does not require unlimited material accumulation is far from new.
In Plato’s Republic, the contrast between a city organised around basic needs and one transformed by luxury and expansion raises enduring questions about moderation, justice and the social consequences of excessive desire [12].
Epicurus associated a good life with the satisfaction of natural needs, friendship and freedom from unnecessary anxiety [13]. Laozi’s philosophy emphasised simplicity and harmony with the natural order [14].
Henry David Thoreau, in Walden, explored the possibility of a more deliberate life, questioning the assumption that material possessions and economic activity necessarily bring greater freedom [15].
Leo Tolstoy challenged the moral legitimacy of wealth and privilege while advocating simplicity, compassion and a closer relationship with ordinary human needs [16].
Mahatma Gandhi placed particular emphasis on self-restraint, village economies, nonviolence and the distinction between human needs and unlimited greed. His vision of self-sufficiency was not simply an economic model, but a political and ethical challenge to domination and excessive consumption [17].
E.F. Schumacher’s Small Is Beautiful later offered a critique of economic systems that measure progress primarily through scale, productivity and growth, rather than human wellbeing and ecological balance [18].
Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings, through the contrast between the Shire and the destructive industrial ambitions of domination, offers another literary reflection on the value of modest living, community and respect for nature [19].
These traditions are not identical, and none provides a complete blueprint for contemporary global policy. Yet they converge on a fundamental insight: the quality of human life cannot be measured by the volume of material possessions or the speed of economic expansion.
Simple living should not be confused with poverty, deprivation or a romantic rejection of modern medicine, science and technology.
It means ensuring that everyone has access to the essentials of a dignified life while reducing unnecessary consumption, waste and dependence on systems that exploit people and nature.
It means valuing time, relationships, care, community, creativity and connection with the natural world.
A society in which people have enough, and in which everyone has the opportunity to live well, may be more sustainable and more humane than one in which a minority accumulates endlessly while others lack the means to meet basic needs.
- What civil society is telling the COP process
The criticism of the COP process is not confined to a small group of environmental activists. A wide range of civil society organisations and independent observers have raised concerns about the scale, transparency, influence and effectiveness of climate negotiations.
Greenpeace and other environmental organisations have repeatedly called for stronger action on fossil fuels and a transition that is not undermined by corporate influence [20].
Amnesty International has stressed the human rights implications of climate change and the importance of protecting communities affected by fossil fuel extraction and environmental destruction [21].
Human Rights Watch has highlighted the gap between climate commitments and the protection of people whose lives, health and livelihoods are threatened by environmental degradation [22].
Extinction Rebellion and other climate movements have challenged the political normalisation of ecological emergency and demanded that governments act in accordance with scientific evidence [23].
During COP31, these concerns have again been visible. Reporting by the Kick Big Polluters Out coalition identified more than 100 companies and industry associations linked to major polluting interests with delegations at the conference [24]. The Guardian reported that these included fossil fuel companies, financial institutions, industrial agriculture, technology businesses and other cross-sector organisations [25].
Transparency International has also raised concerns about the absence of sufficiently robust safeguards against conflicts of interest and undue influence in the COP process [26].
These reports do not demonstrate that every business representative or participant is acting improperly. Nor do they invalidate the role of businesses in developing and implementing climate solutions. They do, however, underline the importance of transparency, disclosure and independent oversight.
A climate conference cannot credibly negotiate the transformation of the global economy while leaving the influence of the most powerful economic interests insufficiently scrutinised.
The COP process must be open to civil society, indigenous peoples, local communities, independent science and vulnerable countries, with safeguards to ensure that participation does not translate into disproportionate power for those with the greatest financial resources.
- Global governance must serve humanity, not competing privileges
Climate change is a global problem requiring collective decisions. Yet international governance remains fragmented by national interests, geopolitical competition, economic privileges and unequal political power.
The consensus-based decision-making system of the COPs has helped preserve the participation of all countries, including small and vulnerable states. It also risks allowing a small number of governments to obstruct decisions supported by a much broader majority.
This dilemma should not be resolved by simply imposing the will of powerful countries on weaker ones. Any reform must protect the political equality and legitimate interests of small states and vulnerable populations.
But a system in which the interests of a few can repeatedly prevent collective action also requires reconsideration [27].
A more effective global governance framework should combine universal participation with transparent procedures, accountability and carefully designed decision-making mechanisms. It should protect the rights of vulnerable countries while making it more difficult for any government or powerful interest to block action essential to humanity’s common future.
The same principle applies to global public goods. Knowledge, scientific cooperation, essential medicines, climate information and technologies that support ecological sustainability should be treated as resources for humanity, not merely as instruments of geopolitical competition or private accumulation.
The climate crisis also exposes the contradiction between enormous military expenditure and the unmet needs of billions of people. Resources devoted to competition, weapons and geopolitical domination should be considered in relation to the investments required for health, education, food security, ecological restoration and climate adaptation.
A sustainable global order requires a shift from competition for privilege towards collaboration for shared wellbeing.
- Beyond the COP: a different set of priorities
If COP31 is to contribute to a meaningful transformation, its legacy should not be measured only by the number of declarations signed, the volume of financial pledges or the diplomatic language adopted.
It should be measured by whether it helps establish a new relationship between human wellbeing, economic activity and the natural world.
The following priorities are proposed for future climate conferences:
- Establish a universal ethical carbon framework.
Recognise the proposed 1.6 tonnes of CO₂ per person per year, including approximately 0.6 tonnes allocated to essential collective services and infrastructures, as a basis for transparent discussion of fair individual and collective responsibility. Develop clear accounting methods and regular independent review. - Require ecological accountability from political leaders.
Encourage all ministers, negotiators and senior public representatives to measure, disclose and progressively reduce their carbon footprints, including the emissions associated with official travel and consumption. - Publish the full financial and ecological cost of every COP.
Include public expenditure, infrastructure, travel, accommodation, energy, materials, waste and emissions, alongside an assessment of the actual benefits achieved. - Reduce the unnecessary scale and carbon intensity of international meetings.
Use smaller delegations, regional preparatory meetings, remote participation where appropriate and more efficient organisation, while protecting the meaningful participation of vulnerable countries and civil society. - Transform production and consumption.
Move beyond technological substitution towards reductions in unnecessary material and energy use, longer product lifespans, repair, reuse, local production and regenerative economic systems. - Strengthen local food sovereignty and community resilience.
Support agroecology, sustainable land management, biodiversity, local distribution and access to healthy food, while ensuring that international cooperation protects essential food and medical supply chains. - Put social justice at the centre of ecological transition.
Guarantee access to essential services and dignified living conditions, address extreme inequalities in resources and consumption, and ensure that those who have contributed least to the crisis are not made to bear its greatest costs. - Reform global governance and protect the public interest.
Strengthen transparency, accountability and safeguards against conflicts of interest, while ensuring that the voices of vulnerable countries, indigenous peoples and local communities are not overshadowed by powerful governments and corporations. - Direct technology and AI towards the global good.
Assess their full ecological footprint and ensure that scientific innovation, digital infrastructure and financial systems contribute to health, equity, ecological restoration and shared knowledge rather than reinforcing concentration of wealth and power.
These priorities are not a substitute for the Paris Agreement or for the urgent need to reduce fossil fuel emissions. They are an attempt to address the deeper social and economic conditions that determine whether climate commitments can be achieved.
- The real measure of success
The COP process was created because humanity recognised that climate change cannot be solved by individual countries acting alone. That recognition remains valid and more urgent than ever.
But international cooperation must be judged by its capacity to transform reality, not by the continuity of its institutions.
The climate crisis is inseparable from the health crisis, the crisis of inequality, the loss of biodiversity, the depletion of natural resources and the concentration of economic and political power.
A world that continues to produce and consume without regard to ecological limits cannot be made sustainable simply by changing its energy sources. A world that tolerates extreme inequality cannot achieve a just ecological transition. And a global governance system that protects privileges more effectively than human dignity cannot provide the leadership required.
The proposed universal ethical threshold is an invitation to rethink responsibility, not to impose deprivation. Its purpose is to make it possible for everyone to live with dignity, with sufficient resources for health, education, food, shelter, mobility and participation in society, while respecting the ecological conditions on which all life depends.
This requires a different understanding of prosperity: less unnecessary consumption, more equitable access to essential resources, stronger communities, local resilience and global solidarity.
The true measure of climate diplomacy will not be how many people gather in a conference centre, how many declarations are signed, or how many investments are announced. It will be whether the lives of people and the health of ecosystems improve as a consequence of the decisions taken.
COP31 should therefore confront a question that reaches beyond the conference itself:
If the global climate process cannot establish a universal ethical responsibility, challenge excessive production and consumption, and demonstrate that political leaders are prepared to live by the principles they advocate, what kind of transformation is it actually asking humanity to undertake?
The alternative is not a return to poverty or technological stagnation. It is a future in which scientific progress, renewable energy, circular economies and global collaboration serve a more fundamental objective: enabling all people to live well, simply and with dignity, within the limits of a shared planet.
1.6 tonnes collectively, approximately one tonne of individual responsibility, dignity for all, and no exemption from ecological accountability for those who govern.
References
- United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (2015). The Paris Agreement.
https://unfccc.int/process-and-meetings/the-paris-agreement - Garay, J. (2025). COP30 Confirms the Near-Irreversible Path to Human Self-Destruction and Ecocide. PEAH – Policies for Equitable Access to Health.
https://www.peah.it/2025/11/cop30-confirms-the-near-irreversible-path-to-human-self-destruction-and-ecocide/ - Earth.Org (2026). COP31: Week 1 Recap. 14 November 2026.
https://earth.org/cop31-week-1-recap/ - IPCC (2023). Climate Change 2023: Synthesis Report. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/syr/ - United Nations Environment Programme (2024). Emissions Gap Report 2024.
https://www.unep.org/resources/emissions-gap-report-2024 - Global Carbon Project. Global Carbon Budget. Annual assessment of global carbon emissions and carbon sinks.
https://globalcarbonproject.org/ - Garay, J. (2024). Human Ethical Threshold of CO₂ Emissions and Projected Life Lost by Excess Emissions. PEAH.
https://www.peah.it/2024/07/13556/ - Garay, J. (2024). Homo Interitans: Countries that Escape, So Far, the Human Bio-Suicidal Trend. PEAH.
https://www.peah.it/2024/09/13667/ - Garay, J. (2024). Enough is Enough, and More is Too Much: Between Basic Dignity and Excess/Hoarding Thresholds. PEAH.
https://www.peah.it/2024/11/enough-is-enough-and-more-is-too-much-between-basic-dignity-and-excess-hoarding-thresholds/ - Garay, J. (2025). The Sustainable Wellbeing Equity Index. PEAH.
https://www.peah.it/2025/01/14273/ - Garay, J. (2025). The Inequity Risks of AI When the Global Good Is Not the Goal. PEAH.
https://www.peah.it/2025/09/15065/ - Plato. The Republic. Particularly Book II, on the emergence of the city, needs, luxury and justice.
- Epicurus. Letter to Menoeceus and Principal Doctrines.
- Laozi. Tao Te Ching.
- Thoreau, H. D. (1854). Walden; or, Life in the Woods.
- Tolstoy, L. (1886). What Then Must We Do?; and (1893) The Kingdom of God Is Within You.
- Gandhi, M. K. Sarvodaya and writings on self-restraint, village self-sufficiency and nonviolence.
- Schumacher, E. F. (1973). Small Is Beautiful: A Study of Economics as if People Mattered. Blond & Briggs.
- Tolkien, J. R. R. (1954–1955). The Lord of the Rings. George Allen & Unwin.
- Greenpeace International. Climate and Energy.
https://www.greenpeace.org/international/ - Amnesty International. Climate Change and Human Rights.
https://www.amnesty.org/en/what-we-do/climate-change/ - Human Rights Watch. Climate Change and Human Rights.
https://www.hrw.org/topic/climate-change - Extinction Rebellion. About Extinction Rebellion.
https://rebellion.global/ - Kick Big Polluters Out (2026). Big Polluters at the COP31 Climate Talks. 13 November 2026.
https://kickbigpollutersout.org/Big-Polluters-COP31 - Milman, O. (2026). More than 100 Companies and Groups Linked to Fossil Fuels Represented at COP31, Study Says. The Guardian, 13 November 2026.
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2026/nov/13/cop31-companies-and-groups-linked-to-fossil-fuels-delegations - Transparency International (2026). COP31 Begins with Trust at Stake as Integrity Safeguards Remain Missing. 5 November 2026.
https://www.transparency.org/en/press/cop31-begins-with-trust-at-stake-integrity-safeguards-remain-missing - Mouterde, P. (2026). COP31: Can Global Climate Conferences Be Reformed? Le Monde, 8 November 2026.
https://www.lemonde.fr/en/environment/article/2026/11/08/cop31-can-global-climate-conferences-be-reformed_6775144_114.html
Note on the ethical threshold: The 1.6-tonne total and its proposed allocation between essential collective services and individual responsibility are an ethical proposal advanced in this article. They should not be confused with an official UNFCCC or IPCC standard. Their application requires transparent accounting, scientific scrutiny and equitable treatment of different needs and circumstances.
